Koh Mak vs Koh Phi Phi
See how these destinations compare for your trip.
Choose two different destinations to compare.
Not sure where to go? Find my destination
A quieter setting
Low-key development and a relaxed pace make peaceful stays easy to find.
A livelier nightlife scene
Beach bars and late venues create a lively scene around the main village, while quieter bays offer a different pace. Another assessed advantage: more island-hopping options.
Side by side
What feels different
Our editorial assessments · Select a factor to see how we scored each place.
Why we rate Koh Mak 8/10
Several attractive, quiet beaches suit swimming and relaxed days, though the island has fewer choices than larger beach destinations.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 9/10
Phi Phi Don has striking coves and beaches, although the busiest areas can be crowded and some quieter shores need a boat.
What we assess
Beach appeal, convenient access and variety during a beach-focused stay, within the destination itself.
Why we rate Koh Mak 7/10
Low hills, coconut groves and sheltered bays make a pleasant, peaceful landscape rather than a dramatic one.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 10/10
Steep limestone cliffs, bright bays and jungle viewpoints make the island scenery a standout.
What we assess
The visual impact of natural surroundings and how central those landscapes are to a typical stay.
Why we rate Koh Mak 3/10
Small villages and local plantations offer a little island context, but there are few major visitor-facing heritage sights.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 2/10
The island’s visitor experience is focused on beaches and boat trips, with few major heritage sights.
What we assess
The variety, depth and practical access to historic places, temples, architecture, traditions and cultural experiences during a typical stay.
Why we rate Koh Mak 5/10
Thai meals and seafood are available at resorts and a few local restaurants, with limited variety across the island.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 6/10
Thai seafood and international dishes are widely available around the main village, with less variety away from it.
What we assess
Food quality, variety, distinctive local cooking and how readily visitors can find good places to eat, regardless of price.
Why we rate Koh Mak 2/10
The island is geared to quiet evenings, with only a small number of casual bars.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 8/10
Beach bars and late venues create a lively scene around the main village, while quieter bays offer a different pace.
What we assess
The choice, variety and liveliness of evening venues, their opening hours and how easily you can enjoy a typical night out.
Why we rate Koh Mak 9/10
Low-key development and a relaxed pace make peaceful stays easy to find.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 4/10
Quiet stays are possible outside the main village, but crowds, boat traffic and nightlife make peaceful bases less typical.
What we assess
How easily you can enjoy a peaceful stay, considering traffic, nightlife noise, crowds and practical quieter bases.
Why we rate Koh Mak 5/10
Nearby islands and snorkelling sites can be visited by boat, but excursions are limited and often seasonal.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 9/10
Frequent boats make nearby bays, snorkelling stops and Phi Phi Leh accessible, with day-trip traffic especially strong in peak periods.
What we assess
The variety of worthwhile sea-island trips, convenient departures, journey times and flexibility under normal operating conditions.
Why we rate Koh Mak 8/10
The small island is well suited to cycling, with resort taxis and arranged rides for longer trips. Walking alone will not connect every beach or stay.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 7/10
The main village is walkable and boats reach other bays, but luggage, hills and longer island trips require planning.
What we assess
Freedom to explore without renting a scooter, using walking, public transport, taxis, tuk-tuks, ride-hailing or boats; transport price is assessed separately.
Why we rate Koh Mak 5/10
Basic stays and local food help, while limited transport, boat connections and accommodation choice raise the cost of reaching and exploring the island.
Why we rate Koh Phi Phi 4/10
Budget rooms and meals are available, but island logistics, excursion costs and high visitor demand can raise the overall spend.
What we assess
How easily you can enjoy a typical stay on a modest budget, including simple accommodation, food, realistic transport and characteristic activities.
Scores out of 10 · Higher means more of that characteristic About these scores
How to read the scale
Scores run from 0 to 10 and describe how strongly a destination offers each characteristic.
Higher does not always mean better
A higher nightlife score means a livelier scene. A higher quietness score means a calmer atmosphere. The right balance depends on your trip.
Close scores mean similar experiences
Small differences should not decide your trip on their own.
Koh Mak
Choose Koh Mak if...
- You want peaceful beach days on a small island with a relaxed pace.
- You like the idea of cycling between coconut groves, local stops and beach areas.
- You prefer a few simple outings and quiet evenings to a packed itinerary.
The trade-off
Restaurant, nightlife and excursion choices are limited compared with larger islands. Some beach areas are a longer ride apart, and boat connections still need planning around their schedules.
Koh Phi Phi
Choose Koh Phi Phi if...
- You want limestone bays, coastal viewpoints and striking island scenery.
- You want snorkelling and boat outings, including trips to nearby Phi Phi Leh.
- You like a lively island village with beach bars and restaurants close together.
The trade-off
Crowds, boat traffic and late-night noise are common around the main village. Quieter bays can mean boat transfers, and island accommodation and excursions can stretch a modest budget.
Plan your trip
When to go
See how temperature, rainfall and travel conditions change through the year. Select a month to focus your comparison.
| Factor | Koh Mak | Koh Phi Phi |
|---|---|---|
| Average daytime high | 32°C | 33°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 51 mm | 97 mm |
| Rainy days | 4.9 | 7.7 |
| Crowds | High | High |
| Stay prices | High | High |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Calm |
| Average daytime high | 32°C | 34°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 82 mm | 36 mm |
| Rainy days | 7.4 | 4.3 |
| Crowds | High | High |
| Stay prices | High | High |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Calm |
| Average daytime high | 33°C | 35°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 140 mm | 108 mm |
| Rainy days | 12.6 | 8.3 |
| Crowds | High | High |
| Stay prices | High | High |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Calm |
| Average daytime high | 33°C | 34°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 196 mm | 142 mm |
| Rainy days | 14.9 | 12.7 |
| Crowds | Moderate | Moderate |
| Stay prices | Typical | Typical |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Calm |
| Average daytime high | 33°C | 33°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 420 mm | 210 mm |
| Rainy days | 21.9 | 17.5 |
| Crowds | Low | Low |
| Stay prices | Low | Low |
| Sea conditions | Variable | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 32°C | 32°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 777 mm | 225 mm |
| Rainy days | 25.4 | 17.5 |
| Crowds | Low | Low |
| Stay prices | Low | Low |
| Sea conditions | Rough | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 31°C | 32°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 1024 mm | 222 mm |
| Rainy days | 26.6 | 17.6 |
| Crowds | Low | Low |
| Stay prices | Low | Low |
| Sea conditions | Rough | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 31°C | 32°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 970 mm | 273 mm |
| Rainy days | 27 | 18.2 |
| Crowds | Low | Low |
| Stay prices | Low | Low |
| Sea conditions | Rough | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 31°C | 31°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 816 mm | 286 mm |
| Rainy days | 24.8 | 19.2 |
| Crowds | Low | Low |
| Stay prices | Low | Low |
| Sea conditions | Rough | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 32°C | 31°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 338 mm | 293 mm |
| Rainy days | 21.3 | 20.6 |
| Crowds | Moderate | Low |
| Stay prices | Typical | Low |
| Sea conditions | Variable | Rough |
| Average daytime high | 33°C | 31°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 85 mm | 199 mm |
| Rainy days | 9.1 | 17.5 |
| Crowds | High | Moderate |
| Stay prices | High | Typical |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Variable |
| Average daytime high | 32°C | 32°C |
| Monthly Rainfall | 28 mm | 90 mm |
| Rainy days | 3.5 | 11.1 |
| Crowds | High | High |
| Stay prices | High | High |
| Sea conditions | Calm | Calm |
| Destination | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May | Jun | Jul | Aug | Sep | Oct | Nov | Dec |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average daytime high | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak |
32°C
|
32°C
|
33°C
|
33°C
|
33°C
|
32°C
|
31°C
|
31°C
|
31°C
|
32°C
|
33°C
|
32°C
|
| Koh Phi Phi |
33°C
|
34°C
|
35°C
|
34°C
|
33°C
|
32°C
|
32°C
|
32°C
|
31°C
|
31°C
|
31°C
|
32°C
|
| Monthly Rainfall | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak |
51 mm
|
82 mm
|
140 mm
|
196 mm
|
420 mm
|
777 mm
|
1024 mm
|
970 mm
|
816 mm
|
338 mm
|
85 mm
|
28 mm
|
| Koh Phi Phi |
97 mm
|
36 mm
|
108 mm
|
142 mm
|
210 mm
|
225 mm
|
222 mm
|
273 mm
|
286 mm
|
293 mm
|
199 mm
|
90 mm
|
| Rainy days | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak | 4.9 | 7.4 | 12.6 | 14.9 | 21.9 | 25.4 | 26.6 | 27 | 24.8 | 21.3 | 9.1 | 3.5 |
| Koh Phi Phi | 7.7 | 4.3 | 8.3 | 12.7 | 17.5 | 17.5 | 17.6 | 18.2 | 19.2 | 20.6 | 17.5 | 11.1 |
| Crowds | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak | High | High | High | Moderate | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | High | High |
| Koh Phi Phi | High | High | High | Moderate | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Moderate | High |
| Stay prices | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak | High | High | High | Typical | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Typical | High | High |
| Koh Phi Phi | High | High | High | Typical | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Low | Typical | High |
| Sea conditions | ||||||||||||
| Koh Mak | Calm | Calm | Calm | Calm | Variable | Rough | Rough | Rough | Rough | Variable | Calm | Calm |
| Koh Phi Phi | Calm | Calm | Calm | Calm | Rough | Rough | Rough | Rough | Rough | Rough | Variable | Calm |
Temperatures are historical average daytime highs, not the highest temperatures you might experience. Rainfall and rainy days are monthly averages, not a forecast. A rainy day need not mean rain all day.
Stay prices are relative to each destination’s usual rates. Holidays can bring extra crowds and higher prices. Sea conditions vary by beach and day; check local conditions before boat trips.
Koh Mak: Thai Meteorological Department — TRAT, 1991–2020.
Koh Phi Phi: Thai Meteorological Department — KRABI, 1994–2020.
